For the Love of Ranch, Stop Buying Salad Dressing and Make Your Own


with Michael Kimball
Test Kitchen Chef
May 24, 2019
Print Facebook Twitter Pinterest Email
For the Love of Ranch, Stop Buying Salad Dressing and Make Your Own

Let’s be real. Green salads aren’t always thrilling to the senses. But we gotta get our chlorophyll somehow so we coin some carrots, dice a tomato, and bust out the beloved bottle of ranch to turn a literal pile of leaves into a much better tasting pile of leaves.

The difference is in the dressing.

You probably have a couple bottles in your fridge right now. How long have they been in there? No one knows. Are you ever going to finish that bottle of Italian dressing? No one knows that either, but what I do know is that making your own salad dressing will not only free up some valuable real estate in your fridge, it will also give you the opportunity to control what you put into your body. And in case you were wondering, there are five levels of salad dressing making mastery. Which sounds most like you?

Level 1:
Does the lettuce on my taco count as salad? (No.)

Level 2:
Calls all salad dressings ranch. Greatest strength: understands that “ranch” is great on things besides salad. Is often observed pouring liberally over potatoes, chicken, pizza, and directly into mouth.

Level 3:
Uses a salad spinner. Probably knows what an emulsifier is. Looks at the labels of store-bought dressings and thinks, “I wish there was a better way”.

Level 4:
Knows the “better way”. Can whip up a salad dressing from scratch with ingredients on hand. Also knows when to get a little help and always has a pack of Red Bell Ranch, Green Goddess, or Bleu Cheese in their cupboard for zero(ish) effort homemade dressings that sources (me) say often lead to increased vegetable consumption. Receives daily compliments on glowing, radiant skin from friends, coworkers, and grocery clerks... Probably because they eat so much salad.

Level 5:
Can make salad dressing with their mind.

Whatever level you currently identify with (perhaps all of them, depending on the day) I have a couple tips to help you level up your greens game.

Tips on How to Make Homemade Salad Dressing

Tip 1:
Know your key players:

  • Oil
  • Acid
  • An emulsifier (binding agent)
  • Salt

A solid ratio for a vinaigrette to have in your brain is 9:3:1.

9 parts oil, 3 parts acid, and 1 part emulsifier. The amount of salt you add totally depends on taste and if any of your other ingredients contain salt. I often go a little lighter on the oil and heavier on the sweet, sour, and salty ingredients, but it’s a good starting point.

Tip 2:
I know we both already know what an emulsifier is, but let’s review anyways. Emulsifiers are able to bind to both oil and water, creating a homogenous mixture that is much less likely to separate. Mustard, mayo, egg yolk, and honey are the most common/best.

Tip 3:
Taste your dressing and adjust. Need some zing? Add a squeeze of citrus or some capers. Need a little somethin’ somethin’? Add anchovies or a splash of Worcestershire. The best part about making your own dressings is that they are endlessly customizable. You can make them just how you like them.

Tip 4:
Put your spice rack to WORK. Curry powders, herbs, aromatics, and chiles are quintessential candidates to get the flavor job done.

Tip 5:
Think beyond dressings with the textures and flavors you can add to spruce up your less-than-charming chard. Crunchy croissant croutons, tender toasted pine nuts, puckersome pickled red onions, tangy pickled mustard seeds, or smokey sweet grilled corn would do it.

For more inspiration, check out our library of nearly 100 salad and salad dressing recipes. Submit your own salad related recipes here and tag us on Instagram with evidence that you have ascended to level 5. Or just like a nice picture of some kale. Dressed, of course.

Comments on this Article

(guest), on May 30, 2020

Loved this article! Just enough information to get me started, and written with a sense of humor. Thank you for brightening y day!

(guest), on May 30, 2020

I'm a regular customer of Mary's store on El Paseo in P Desert Calif and I shop when we are there at our vacay home. But I can't access the "recipes section" as the application for a first time online purchases is blocking me from accessing the recipes section. I'm not going to order any products online as I like to shop in person. Is there another way I can acc the recipes section and use some of the spices etc I have bought from the PD store and I have here at home, Thankyou Debbie Baxter North Van BC Canada

(guest), on May 30, 2020

I am inspired! Especially since my baby lettuce is coming up and ready to be thinned

(guest), on May 30, 2020

What a great article! Thank you. I needed some inspiration to zip up my salads. I even like drizzling dressing it over roasted vegetables.

(guest), on May 30, 2020

Great article- it’s really got my “little gray cells” moving! I’m excited to try it out for myself.

(guest), on June 01, 2020

Is using too much acid-to-oil making my dressing explode? It blows the top off the bottle! I have been using more lemon juice, little olive oil.

Add a comment:


Email Address: (will not be made public)

To help us reduce spam please click on the symbols in the image below
Captcha Button - Yes Captcha Button - No Captcha Button - Yes Captcha Button - No Captcha Button - Yes Captcha Button - Yes Captcha Button - No Captcha Button - Yes