Best Sellers

Buy One, Get One 50% OFF all Refill Bags with code REFILL50. Mix & match flavors.

These are our top-selling spice blends, herbs, and seasonings. Use for all types of cooking, grilling or baking. Great for seasoning chicken, pork, steak, burgers, vegetables, popcorn, and vegan cooking.

Why We Love These Spices

Tried & True Favorites

These are the spices our customers reach for year after year. Consistently loved for their flavor, versatility, and reliability, these classics have earned their place in everyday cooking. They’re the blends our customers trust for weeknight dinners, special occasions, and the recipes they make on repeat.

Top-Rated: Capitol Hill Seasoning
A Savory Spice Original
: Red Rocks Hickory Smoke Seasoning
Reordered Again & Again
: Taco Seasoning

Where to Start

Not sure what to try first? Start here! These best sellers are long-time customer favorites that are approachable, versatile, and easy to use across a wide range of recipes. Whether you’re replenishing your pantry or discovering Savory Spice for the first time, these are the spices and seasonings we recommend trying first. They’re simple ways to make your most favorite meals taste noticeably better.

For Meats & Grilling: Pikes Peak Butcher's Rub
For Vegetables: Black Garlic Salt
For Sauces & Soups: Italian Herbs
For Baked Goods & Desserts: Pure Madagascar Vanilla Extract

Rethinking the Basics

Sometimes the biggest upgrade is rethinking what you already use the most. This collection is full of better-for-everyday alternatives to common pantry staples. Seasonings that do more with less effort. More depth, more balance, more flavor. Swap these in for the basics you cook with all the time and discover how small changes can transform familiar meals.

Upgrade Garlic & Onion Powder: Onion & Garlic Everyday Seasoning
Upgrade Ground Cinnamon: Supreme Saigon Cinnamon
Upgrade Italian Herbs: Cantanzaro Herbs
Upgrade Black Pepper: Whiskey Barrel Smoked Black Pepper or Four Corners Peppercorn Medley

Thoughtfully Packaged

Our jars and bags are designed with both the planet and your kitchen in mind. Jars now feature recyclable aluminum lids, while refill bags are made with a multi-layer film containing 90% recycled PET and 25% recycled EVOH/LLDPE, helping reduce reliance on new plastic materials. Peek-through windows and lid-top labels make spices easier to find and use, all in a cleaner, elevated design that reflects the quality inside every jar.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the best way to store spices to keep them fresh?

To keep your spices flavorful, store them in a cool, dry place away from heat, humidity, and direct sunlight. A pantry or cabinet near–not above–your stove is ideal. Make sure lids are tightly closed after each use to lock in freshness. Because we handcraft our blends in small batches, proper storage helps preserve the bold, vibrant flavor we put into every jar.

How long do spices and seasonings typically last before they lose flavor?

Whole spices can stay flavorful for 2-3 years, while ground spices and seasoning blends are best within 1-2 years. They are shelf stable and won’t “go bad” in a harmful way, but their aroma and potency naturally fade over time. For the freshest flavor experience, give your spices a quick smell–if the aroma isn’t strong, it’s likely time to refresh your jar. You can refill your jars anytime with our spice Refill Bags, plus you can save more when you buy more refills!

Do spices and seasonings expire?

Spices don’t truly expire, which is why you won't find many jars with expiration dates. However, they do lose flavor as they sit on your shelves. Because we make everything in small batches, our spices start fresher–and stay vibrant longer–than other store bought or mass-produced options. If a spice looks dull, has a weak aroma, or no longer delivers the punch it once did, it’s simply past its peak and ready to be replaced.

When should I add spices and seasonings to foods while cooking?

It ultimately depends on the spice. Ground spices and blends shine when added early, giving them time to bloom in heat and oil or fat. Whole spices can be toasted or simmered longer to release their full aroma. For delicate herbs or finishing blends, add them toward the end of cooking to preserve their brightness. When in doubt, always season in layers–your food will taste deeper, richer, and more balanced.

*Offer valid online and at participating stores only. Must use code REFILL50 at checkout for buy one, get one 50% off refill bags. 50% off items are of equal or lesser value. Excludes large bags. Other exclusions may apply. No adjustments on past purchases. Cannot be combined with Black Friday rewards, other reward codes, or Loyalty Rewards. This offer expires 11:59 PM MDT, March 22, 2026.

**Must add a jar of Cuban Island Spice to your cart and have an additional $75+ of products, excluding gift cards, in your cart ($50 in-store) to qualify. Offer subject to availability. Cannot be combined with Black Friday rewards, other reward codes, or Loyalty Rewards. Offer expires 11:59PM MDT, March 31, 2026.